Quote:
Originally Posted by Merami fan
I'm actually not a fan of the Macallan 12 yr, specifically the double cask. The 15 is twice as good but not twice as expensive.  Balvenie 15 is also good.
Any Japanese whiskeys in the $60-70 range are solid if you like smooth and smokey. Ex: Suntory Hibiki
Cutty Sark Prohibition Edition (blended) is a good cheaper bottle.
Glenfiddich 14 and higher.
Any Glenmorangie.
Highland Park 18.
Any Lagavulin.
Any Oban.
Dalmore 12/15 for sherry and orange notes.
Wild Turkey, Buffalo Trace, Woodford Reserve (double oaked) for bourbon. |
This is interesting to me. I really don't get a ton of smoke, or a ton of flavor compared to most other stuff, from Japanese whisky. I think they are generally very smooth and have a lighter palate that allows for some good subtle notes - but I have not had one that knocked my socks off. They are also pricey for what you get IMO.
The Oban is another one, a good drink but just overly expensive for what you are getting. I think most of the Highland Park are good offerings for an entry level of smoke (even the 12 is pretty good IMO)
I was a lot more into Scotch but anymore I really find the American whiskey to hit my palate better, that and Islay Scotches so maybe take my opinion with a grain of salt.